Of 17 votes cast so far, **It's real, but only as self-perception — not biology.** The most accurate answer is probably the least satisfying one: both sides are half right. The biological claims — the specific testosterone and cortisol shifts — did not replicate in larger, more rigorous studies, and treating them as settled science was always premature. That part of the popular narrative should be retired. But subjective, self-reported confidence is a different story. [color=purple]Multiple studies still find[/color] that when people are instructed to stand or sit in more expansive postures, they *describe* feeling calmer and more in control afterward, similar to how other simple behavioral rituals — a pre-game routine, a power outfit, a rehearsed opening line — can shift someone's mindset without doing anything to their hormones. That's a real psychological phenomenon worth taking seriously, even if the mechanism is expectation and self-perception rather than biochemistry. Power posing might genuinely help you *feel* ready — it just doesn't turn you into someone else on a cellular level. leads with 41%.
**The core effect is real — poses shift confidence and behavior.** The headline hormone claims — that a two-minute pose measurably raises testosterone and lowers cortisol — were the weakest part of the original study, and it's fair that those specific numbers didn't hold up in larger replications. But throw out the hormones and there's still a real, repeatable finding underneath: how you physically hold your body changes how you feel and how you act, even if the mechanism isn't glandular. Multiple follow-up studies, including some of the same larger replications that debunked the hormone claims, still found that people who adopted expansive postures *reported* feeling more powerful, took on more financial risk in decision-making tasks, and were rated by outside observers as more confident during interviews. [color=green]That's not nothing[/color] — it just means the honest version of "power posing works" is a psychological and behavioral effect, not a biological one. Treating the whole idea as debunked throws out a real, useful finding along with an overstated one. is second on 29%, 12 points behind.
Everyone who has answered so far is voting from China.
The most recent vote came in 10 days ago.
Never miss a new question
One email per question, straight to your inbox. Unsubscribe anytime.