Of 16 votes cast so far, He should stay retired. Donald left the game as a three-time Defensive Player of the Year and one of the greatest interior defensive linemen ever; coming back at 35 after two years away risks a diminished, injury-shortened final chapter that could complicate an otherwise flawless legacy, which is why some Rams legends have publicly urged him not to return. leads with 38%.
It only makes sense in this specific context. A comeback is worth the risk mainly because of the Myles Garrett trade and the current state of the Rams' roster; without that specific opportunity to chase a championship now, this wouldn't be worth the risk to his health or legacy at all. is second on 38%, close enough that a handful of votes could still turn it around.
Everyone who has answered so far is voting from China.
The most recent vote came in 4 days ago.