Messi just missed his third straight penalty as Inter Miami got embarrassed 4-1 by Nashville — what's the real story here?

Inter Miami's trip to Nashville turned into one of the roughest nights of their season. Nashville won 4-1, with Andy Najar heading one in early, Hany Mukhtar scoring twice in the second half, and Sam Surridge adding a fourth — a genuinely dominant, complete performance rather than a scrappy upset. Miami's only goal came from Telasco Segovia right before halftime, and Messi did pick up an assist on the build-up, but the header of the night belonged to Nashville from start to finish.

The moment everyone is actually talking about, though, is Messi's penalty. In the first half he stepped up and had his spot-kick saved by Nashville keeper Brian Schwake; in second-half stoppage time he struck the post — twice missing real chances to drag Miami back into the match. That's now three straight penalty misses for Messi by most counts, following two misses at the FIFA World Cup 2026 earlier this year. For a player whose entire career has been built partly on being automatic from twelve yards, a stretch like this is jarring enough that it's dominating the conversation more than the scoreline itself, and Messi also picked up a yellow card in the second half as the game slipped away.

The context matters too. This loss snapped Miami's seven-match unbeaten run in MLS and is a rare stumble for a team that's actually been the league's best on the road this season (8-1-1 away from home coming in) — which makes losing this badly at Nashville even more of an outlier. Nashville, meanwhile, sit top of the entire league with 43 points from a 13-2-4 record, two points clear of defending champions Miami in second. It's exactly the kind of result that reshapes how people think about the MLS Cup race down the stretch: is this the league's best team finally getting the credit it deserves, or is it a reminder that Miami's ceiling is still tied to how many of these games Messi can single-handedly drag them through — and what happens when, on a given night, he can't?

🖼️ Bigger images

𝗕 Bold text

Messi's penalty record right now. Missing three straight — a save at Nashville, two misses at the World Cup before that — is a real, statistically strange stretch for someone who has been one of the most reliable penalty takers of his generation. One rough patch doesn't rewrite a career, but at 39 the question of whether this is just variance or an early signal of decline is a legitimate one, and it's clearly rattling him: the frustration was visible all night in Nashville.

Nashville actually being the best team in MLS right now. Topping the league at 43 points on a 13-2-4 record, two clear of the defending champions, isn't a fluke off one big result — it's the product of a full season, and beating Miami this convincingly at home is the strongest possible statement that Nashville deserves to be treated as the team to beat heading into the playoffs, not just a plucky challenger.

Miami's unbeaten streak snapping in the worst possible way. Seven matches without a loss, ended not by a narrow defeat but a 4-1 blowout, and against a team they were supposedly built to handle. What makes it stranger is Miami came in as the league's best road team at 8-1-1 — this wasn't a case of a team that struggles away from home finally getting exposed, it's a genuine, hard-to-explain off night from a team that's normally excellent on the road.

Nashville's attacking depth beyond just "beat a Messi team." Andy Najar's early header, Hany Mukhtar's second-half brace, and Sam Surridge's fourth goal came from three different players, not one talisman carrying the load — which is arguably a healthier formula heading into the playoffs than relying on any single star. It's a quieter story than the Messi headlines, but it might be the more important one for how Nashville's season actually plays out.

What this means for the MLS Cup race. Nashville now has real separation at the top of the table, and a result like this forces a genuine re-ranking of the league's contenders heading into the stretch run and playoffs. Miami is still a very good team with a former Ballon d'Or winner in Messi, but if nights like this become more frequent as the season wears on, home-field advantage and the top playoff seed could realistically slip away from them.

Optional photo for your new option. Take one or choose from your device. Shown as a 200 x 200 pixel thumbnail, cropped from the centre.

✨ Vote to reveal a bonus tea Easter egg!

Submit Anonymous